Bodhi Tree Swaying: Reflections of a Western Buddhist

Hitchens on whether waterboarding is torture

The whole question of whether waterboarding is torture is a bogus one. Nazis were prosecuted at Nuremberg and found guilty of using this precise technique. And the fact that it’s even in question that it may not be torture to drown someone shows how low the current US administration has sunk on the scale of morality.

Nevertheless, because there is a pseudo debate, Christopher Hitchens bravely had himself subjected to waterboarding and describes his experiences in some detail in a Vanity Fair article.

Since the article is entitled “Believe Me, It’s Torture” I don’t need to beware of spoilers.

Some salient points to extract are:

1. The official lie is that this torture technique involves simulated drowning. That’s like saying that giving someone electric shocks is “simulated electrocution” or hanging someone by the neck is simulated hanging.” It’s real drowning, and is torture.

2. Any information extracted is likely to be worthless because people will say anything to make the torture stop.

3. The US can no longer complain if its military personnel are subjected to this torture technique. It has given up the right to do so.

For the record, I think that Hitchens is in many ways a pompous and self-deluding ass — but he’s also a brave man.

Leave a Reply