Michelle Malkin, the neoconservative blogger, and Maureen Dowd, the New York Times’ desperately cynical (and rather liberal) op-ed columnist have something in common today: both pass on misleading statements about Barack Obama’s use of the phrase “God Bless America.”
Malkin has a piece entitled “Newsflash: Obama says “God bless America,” in which she uncritically passes on a comment by the Baltimore Sun: “At a rally shortly before his press conference today, Obama uncharacteristically ended his remarks with the phrase ‘God bless America.’ ”
Dowd says “Newly alert to the perils of not seeming patriotic enough, he ended a speech in Pennsylvania the other morning with “God bless America!’ ”
These people have researchers. They have access to Lexis-Nexus and all those tools that allow you to examine everything that’s been said by anyone of note. So they must be right? Obama doesn’t end speeches by requesting God to bless the United States?
A couple of minutes on Google shows that they are inaccurate (or to put it another way, lazy and incompetent):
July 27, 2004: “Thank you, and God bless America.” (This was Obama’s keynote speech at the Democratic National Convention!)
Feb 25, 2005: May God Bless you, and may God Bless these United States of America.
January 20, 2008: May God bless the memory of the great pastor of this church, and may God bless the United States of America.
Texas, March 5, 2008: “Thank you, San Antonio. God bless you. God bless America.”
Many of the transcripts available online are, moreover, the text of the prepared speech rather than what was actually said. It seems that Obama often invokes blessings spontaneously at the end of his talks, most often ending with “God Bless You.” This means that he may well have used that blessing more often than the available transcripts allow.
I rather like Obama’s unpremeditated approach; it suggests that his closing words are heart-felt rather than prepared and rote. I wish that for every time George Bush had mentioned God he had seriously reflected on what the New Testament actually teaches.
I often have critical words to say about Christians who practice hate or who distort the truth, but I’ll say now that I admire Obama’s Christianity, which strikes me as being compassionate and wise, and embodying the best of Christ’s teachings.